The UK's largest and most visited divorce site.
Modern, convenient and affordable services.

We've helped over 1 million people since 2007.

 
Click this button for details of our
email, phone nbr and free consultations.
 

should dad contribute to childcare costs?

  • Living again
  • Living again's Avatar Posted by
  • Senior Member
  • Senior Member
More
07 Dec 08 #71129 by Living again
Topic started by Living again
Hi all..looking for opinions here or some advice from someone in the know.

I have just gone full time and have been promoted and so as a result stbex and I are now on similar salaries..he still earns a wee bit more than me but not much. He pays me the very basic maintenance of £308 per month (he earns over 40k) and has the kids 2 nights per week.
I know he's not being overly generous with his maintenance but Im glad he's at least paying it!
My question though is this..up until now my child tax credits have covered the cost of the part timee childcare whilst I worked so I havent made an issue at all of who pays childcare costs.
BUT..now that Ive gone full time and my salary has increased, my child tax credit goes down to £10 a week!..yet child care costs have gone up to £80 per week! Given ex and I earn roughly the same..is it fair therefore that I cough up all the childcare costs? should he be contributing in some way? My feeling is that he should be paying some of the childcare costs too rather than it all coming out of my salary!..if I wasnt around..he'd have to pay full whack himself!
thoughts?

  • independentwoman
  • independentwoman's Avatar
  • Senior Member
  • Senior Member
More
07 Dec 08 #71139 by independentwoman
Reply from independentwoman
my stbx and I earn roughly same (about 16-17k- although he has a self employed income on top of that), I won't take any money off him, he hasn't offered, and I pay all childcare (£700 a mth),

Anyway, personally, I prefer not to take a penny off him. I would rather struggle by myself if it is a chore to him to put his hand in his pocket for his kids.

  • fedupaes
  • fedupaes's Avatar
  • Elite Member
  • Elite Member
More
07 Dec 08 #71155 by fedupaes
Reply from fedupaes
I really do not know the answer to this but in my circumstances I have soley paid childcare costs since 1997 and continued to do so when my xtb left in Sept 04.
This was mentioned at FDR but I don't know if that means he should have contributed or not.
Sorry, not much help, but I just had to manage. Even if he should have contributed he will never be made to repay.
I will watch this post as I too would love to know the answer.

  • Itgetsbetter
  • Itgetsbetter's Avatar
  • Platinum Member
  • Platinum Member
More
07 Dec 08 #71156 by Itgetsbetter
Reply from Itgetsbetter
Hi Living again

He could say if you hadn't been promoted and now working full time he wouldn't have to pay more! One thing that makes it hard to comment properly is you don't say how much better off you will be as a result of the promotion.

If it were me I would offer to pay something towards childcare, but would probably not pay half as I would feel that I am not getting the benefit of seeing the children more than 2 days a week

Steve

  • Living again
  • Living again's Avatar Posted by
  • Senior Member
  • Senior Member
More
07 Dec 08 #71160 by Living again
Reply from Living again
Hi guys....thanks for your replies so far. Steve, their dad could see the kids much more often than he does..in fact I would have tried to help him all I could to enable him to do shared care...but he says he cant because of his work...even though he can schedule his own timetable!!
He lives 5 mins away and has the kids over a 4 night block every fortnight. Its a wee bone of contention between us that he DOESNT see the kids more often..he's kinda busy fostering his social life though and life with his new girlfriend :)
sven...my ex was PUSHING me to go full time! lol...he's been pushing me to work full time even when we were married and kids were babies! He's aberdonian ;) He reckoned that it was very unfair that I only worked 28 hours and he worked full time...so now that I've gone full time..he'd better not have an issue with it!!! lol
Keep posting thoughts peeps :)

  • Living again
  • Living again's Avatar Posted by
  • Senior Member
  • Senior Member
More
07 Dec 08 #71161 by Living again
Reply from Living again
here's a thought...he takes them Thursday evening through to the monday morning once fortnightly. I would say it would be fair to ask him therefore to pay his own childcare costs for every second thursay/friday?? would that seem reasonable?

  • Itgetsbetter
  • Itgetsbetter's Avatar
  • Platinum Member
  • Platinum Member
More
07 Dec 08 #71166 by Itgetsbetter
Reply from Itgetsbetter
Hi Living

In my opinion as a father, if he can have them more than 2 days a week. He should do so. I have my 2 over half the time and manage to work full time. I think it boils down to whether he wants time with his children, or time with his new woman!

Obviously if he did have them more then the childcare costs you incur would go down....but he might say that he should pay less child maintenance so you may be no better off!

On the working full time point it is interesting as my STBX feels I should pay her more money even though she works about 20 hours a week to my 40, I have the children over half the time, and I pay over the CSA level of child maintenance. I wish she would go full time and stop bugging me! I would expect your stbx to feel the same!

Steve

Moderators: wikivorce teamrubytuesdaydukeyhadenoughnowTetsSheziLinda SheridanForsetiMitchumWhiteRoseLostboy67WYSPECIALBubblegum11

Do you need help sorting out a fair financial settlement?

Our consultant service offers expert advice and support to help you reach agreement on a fair financial settlement quickly, and for less than a quarter of the cost of using a traditional high street solicitor.

 

We can help you to get a fair financial settlement.

Negotiate a fair deal from £299

Helping you negotiate a fair financial settlement with your spouse (or their solicitor) without going to court.


Financial Mediation from £399

Financial mediation is a convenient and inexpensive way to agree on a fair financial settlement.


Consent Orders from £950

This legally binding agreement defines how assets (e.g. properties and pensions) are to be divided.


Court Support from £299

Support for people who have to go to court to get a fair divorce financial settlement without a solicitor.